BUT IT DID HAPPEN

Yoko is making two lunchboxes in early summer morning. One is for herself to take it to her office. The other is for her own child. She cooks various dishes for the lunchboxes neatly. After making the lunchboxes, she knocks the door of her child’s room, but gets no answer. "Your lunchbox is on the dining table." She says and leaves her house.
In her car at the parking of her apartment, Yoko remembers a scene a week ago. She was giving her students a supplementary lesson at the high school she works at. One of the three schoolgirls who always accompany each other didn’t appear in the lesson. She thought it weird but didn’t really care. Yoko stops remembering and starts the car.
In the Principal room of the high school, Yoko talks with the principal about the incident a week ago. A student killed herself at the school. The principal gives her a manual called "Emergency Response Guide".
Yoko and two school girls, Ryoko and Asuka are sitting in the classroom in the morning. On the table is an IC recorder to record the girls’ utterances. "We were bullying her." Girls confess abruptly. "Why do you lie like that?" Yoko tries to keep her calm but gets upset inside. "Then, what is this interview for?" Yoko cannot answer. Before leaving the classroom, Ryoko asks Yoko " Can we practice for a while before leaving?" Yoko says "Sure. I’ll catch up."
Yoko eats her lunch alone in her car at the parking of the school.
In the afternoon, Yoko is sitting in the same classroom facing the mother of the girl who killed herself. Since she seems to be too pitiful, Yoko can’t start talking. At last, Yoko tells the story. "The investigation is still in the process, but there isn’t any evidence that your daughter was bullied so far." After long silence, the mother asks, "Do you have any children?" "I do," says Yoko. Mother, trying to keeping her calm, "How coould you be that indifferent?" Another long silence. "I’m not indifferent," says Yoko. The mother gazes at Yoko’s face. She finally says, "Could you treat my daughter incident as an accidental death?"
In the music room in the afternoon, Ryoko and Asuka are practicing four handed piano performance. Yoko comes into the room. Girls stop practicing and leave the room as if to ignore Yoko. Yoko stays alone in the room.
Yoko comes home. The lunchbox is left as same as Yoko put it on the dining table in the morning. Yoko opens the lunchbox and starts to eat.
Yoko knocks the door of the child’s room gently. No answer. Yoko slowly opens the door, looks into the room, and closes the door slowly to leave.
Yoko washes the dishes. She washes two lunchboxes neatly. Again and again, she keeps washing the two lunchboxes.

Director: Yuichi Suita
Japan, 2021
15:00 min
nominated for Best Short Film 20MINMAX 2022

Born in kagawa Japan 1985. After High school, he learned 16mm Film Making at the film school in Tokyo. And he also started to work with director Youji Yamada as assistant camera. He learned how to make a film at the studio. And He started to make short film from 2008. His 7th short film “How Beautiful Japanese Morning Is” is shown at some International Short Film Festival, Berlin, Sao Paulo, Tampere, Uppsala. And His 9th short film “the day she commits suicide” is shown at 43rd International Film Festival Rotterdam and 61st Sydney Film Festival. And he participated in Berlinale Talents 2015.

Yuichi Suita, Director of But it did happen (2021)

FAMILY TIES

Movies



  • SPOON

    To escape from everyday life, it's very simple: you need a ladder and a spoon....

  • THE DEBIT CARD

    When the Polish au pair Karina goes grocery shopping with the family’s children, the mother of the family she is working for does not trust her enough to give her the PIN. The relationship between Karina and the family becomes spoiled, which is not without consequences…...

  • MULAQAT (SUB ENG) / SANDSTORM

    Zara, a schoolgirl in Karachi (Pakistan), shares a sensual dance video with her virtual boyfriend, who then blackmails her....

  • BUT IT DID HAPPEN

    The woman had three problems. One is about her own child who became a shut-in. Another is about an other people's child who killed herself by jumping off the roof of her school a week ago. And the last one is that the woman was the class teacher of the child passed away....

  • A FATHER

    Steve receives a gift from his father, with whom he hasn't shared much for so long. Will this gesture bridge the gap between them?...

  • TITAN

    Nathan is a thirteen year old boy. Driven by his new friend Malik, he prepares himself for a strange ritual to become a member of a teens gang....

  • CHILDHOOD FRIENDS

    PAUL and FRANZ have been childhood friends. While waiting in the kindergarten Franz asks Paul if he could take care of his son on the weekend. Paul is confessing he is a paedophile and he doesn‘t want to take the risk. At the end the question is how much trust you will you give a paedophile and how far does friendship go....